UnitedHealthcare reported its latest results earlier today. Both segments beat expectations. I own Cigna and follow the health-insurance industry closely.
UnitedHealthcare’s health-insurance business reported a lower medical-care ratio. Part of the improvement came from reversing prior provisions, but it may still be a positive signal for Cigna, which reports later this month. Cigna’s medical-care ratio was 79% in Q1 2026, below peers, reflecting its focus on commercial insurance and disciplined underwriting. Optum also performed well, although its pharmacy-benefit-management (PBM) business struggled. My current view is that concerns about PBMs may be more smoke than fire.
Overall, the results look positive for Cigna, whose report is due in the coming weeks.
Stephen Hemsley’s return to UnitedHealth appears to be paying off; the company seems to be back on track.
Bryan took over as Cigna’s CEO earlier this month. He has worked at Cigna for more than 22 years, and I hold him in high regard. I look forward to hearing from him on the next earnings call.
UnitedHealth shares rose 8% today while Cigna fell 4%, which makes little sense to me. The market values one company at roughly 22 times earnings and the better-managed business at about 9 times; that gap is difficult for me to understand.
Leave a Reply